My first look at this topic focused on the peculiar and sometimes challenging relationship between the (unpaid) Boards of Directors of Universities, Colleges and Independent Schools and the (paid) Chief Executive Officers of these same schools.
For a good study of this relationship (as well as a readable and entertaining book), I refer you to Belinda Rathbone’s The Boston Raphael: A Mysterious Painting, An Embattled Museum and a Daughter’s Search for the Truth (Godine 2014).
This is the story of a scandal, and the resulting conflict between the Board of Trustees of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts and its charismatic and pioneering Director in the 1960s. With a different cast of characters, it could have had a happier ending.
This relationship between non-profit boards and the leaders they hire is the source of my following observation as a lawyer representing those Presidents and Heads of School: that when offered a top job, the prospective academic executive must put aside their sense of ego gratification to ask several tough questions before accepting the offer.
Admittedly, this is not made easy by the timing of the situation. The Board or its search committee has taken a substantial amount of time—often more than a year—to select a new President from the pool of candidates, customarily with the assistance of a paid professional search firm. Once the search is complete, however, and the surviving finalist is given an offer, the Board usually wants a swift response to that offer.
In my experience, the candidate is wise to slow down the process until he or she knows what they will be getting themself into. The only way to do this is a deep dive into the facts of the situation, which means asking questions. This is something which largely has to be done by the CEO candidate themself; their lawyer can research some of it, but is constrained by only being able to speak to other lawyers.
What are some of the most important questions to ask?
1. What Is the True Financial Situation of the Educational Institution?
This is a tricky as well as difficult question. Often hard, if not impossible, to find in any publicly available information, the answer may be one which the Board contact, let alone the search firm, is unable (or unwilling) to share. Sometimes the board genuinely does not know, or want to fully acknowledge, the answer. Sometimes a less than forthcoming Chief Financial Officer has obscured the true facts. An educational institution is not a publicly traded company, overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission, and backed up by financial statements audited by an outside firm.
Nonetheless, having this information is essential for the prospective candidate contemplating the top leadership job at any school.
A first-time President is particularly at risk for finding himself/herself at a school where financial liabilities suggest the likelihood of merger or closure, a fact of life for an increasing number of educational institutions in today’s economy. If the school does fail, the new President may, however unfairly, find himself/herself blamed for that failure. At least if a downward or desperate financial situation is known, and a client is still determined to take the job, their lawyer may be able to build some additional protections into the employment agreement.
2. What Is the Composition of the Board?
This is another Important piece of information for a presidential candidate to have, as it provides at least some preview of what the new CEO will have to deal with.
How big is the board? So big as to become unwieldy?
How many board members are actually significant financial contributors to the institution? A board of, as an example, 36 persons in which only three or four are important donors to the school, can lead to a situation where some of the board members who give the least, talk the loudest.
And who are the members (other than the Board Chair) with whom the President might be expected to engage on a routine basis? When is the current Board Chair’s term ending, either by term limits or planned resignation or transition? Is there a logical successor, and has the presidential candidate even met or spoken with her or him?
3. Is There an “Elephant in the Room” Which Predisposes the Board Against One or More Sources of Compensation for the President?
Did the Board have an unhappy experience with deferred compensation for a prior President, or is the Board philosophically opposed to awarding bonuses for presidential performance or special achievement? [Such bonuses, increasingly common in the commercial world, will be the topic of a future column.]
Far better to know these vital things ahead of time while still considering the offer.
And although recruiters for lower level C-suite jobs may value a quick response to an offer, if the chosen candidate for the presidency of a College or University or Head of School seeking the information necessary for them to decide whether to accept the difficult top job, gets push-back from the Board, that in itself can be an indication of how the board will deal with a problem within the President’s purview.
Lisa, Theresa and I wish you a good remainder of autumn as the leaves, being full of brilliant color, begin to fall.